Long-chain unsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids (LCUFAs and LCPUFAs, respectively) are the essential components of phospholipids and sphingolipids, major building blocks of plasma and organelle membranes. These molecules are also involved in cell signaling and energy metabolism. Hence, both LCUFAs and LCPUFAs are broadly used as food supplements. However, the role of these fatty acids (FAs) in the self-assembly of misfolded proteins remains unclear. In this study, we investigated the effect of LCUFAs and LCPUFAs, as well as their saturated analogue, on insulin aggregation. Using vibrational circular dichroism, we found that all analyzed FAs reversed the supramolecular chirality of insulin fibrils. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that strong hydrophobic interactions were formed between the long aliphatic tails of FAs and hydrophobic amino acid residues of insulin. We infer that such insulin:FA complexes had different self-assembly mechanisms compared to that of insulin alone, which resulted in the observed reversal of the supramolecular chirality of the amyloid fibrils.